• Coup attemt aftermath
    AboutConfiscationsDecreesOHAL CommissionState of emergency
  • Gladio B Turkey
    About Gladio B in TurkeyJames Corbett about GladioPaul L Williams about GladioSibel Edmonds about Gladio BThe Susurluk scandalOp. Gladio documentary BBC
  • Gülen Movement
    About the Gülen MovementAbout Hanefi AvcıConservative or moderate?Documents and reportsFethullah GulenFETÖGulens intentionsGulen and jihadPersons- Leading figuresStratfor about the MovementStructure The "12 Wise Men"TerrorThe CIA connectionThe Imam's ArmyUS CablesVideos
  • Humen rights
    Human Rights Watch report 2020 TurkeyTurkey 2019 human rights reportReligious freedom reportTorture and ill-treatment
  • Media in Turkey
    About media in TurkeyJournalists in troubleMedia outlets shut downSocial mediaWho controls the media?
  • New Turkey
    Abductions in New TurkeyAbout "The New Turkey"Brain drain in New TurkeyPrisons in New TurkeyTorture in New Turkey
  • Purges
    About purges in TurkeyAcademics for peaceCHP deputiesGülen movementHDP deputiesLawyers in TurkeyMedia in Turkey
  • Sources
  • Terror attacks 2015-19
Web Page Creator
Web Page Creator
 

The new Turkey
"Teacher A"

2-apr-19

Human Rights Watch received reports that in the anti-terror branch of a city in Southeast Turkey, police beat and threatened a 40-year-old man who was a school teacher until dismissed under the state of emergency (called here "teacher A"). His name is known to Human Rights Watch, but withheld in this report at the request of his family, who fear repercussions. Human Rights Watch has communicated full details of the case to the Ministry of Justice. The case is distinct from others in this report because the alleged abuses took place after "teacher A" had been transferred back into police custody from pretrial prison custody.

He was detained in August 2016 and remanded to detention in a T-type closed prison, pending trial for alleged links with FETÖ, the group the authorities accuse of being behind the July 2016 attempted coup. On June 3, 2017 "teacher A" was once again transferred to police custody for questioning at the anti-terror branch and, according to his family, held there until July 17 when he was transferred back to the T-type prison.

"Teacher A's" family reported to Human Rights Watch that they discovered that he had been removed from prison on June 6, when they attempted to visit him and were told by the prison authorities that he had been taken before the prosecutor at the courthouse. On visiting the prosecutor, they discovered he was in fact held at the anti-terror branch, and obtained a written authorization from the prosecutor so that they could visit him there. Granted a meeting in the presence of police officers, the family saw that his face was swollen, and he looked unwell.

When they asked him what had happened he told them that he had been hooded, beaten repeatedly, threatened and forced to identify people and "confess" to crimes. The family reported to Human Rights Watch that on hearing this the
police officers sitting in on the meeting had intervened and promptly ended the meeting.29 On June 9, the family had lodged a formal complaint with the prosecutor, but on July 27 reported to Human Rights Watch that there had been no investigation they knew of, and that "teacher A" had been held in police custody until July 17 when he was transferred
back to prison. 29

six-week period in police custody far exceeds any legal limit, although a state of emergency decree (article 8, decree no. 670) passed in August 2016 permits the prosecutor to grant the police the right to recall a suspect accused of terrorism offenses or crimes against the state for further questioning. The provision does not specify that this includes individuals already remanded to pretrial detention, nor does it mention how long they can be held in police custody for the purpose of giving another statement to the police.30

Cases of remand prisoners being taken out of prison and transferred into police custody for questioning without informing families or lawyers have been reported elsewhere in the media.31 Human Rights Watch considers that the case of "teacher A" demonstrates that transferring remand prisoners back into police custody is a dangerous, unnecessary, and potentially unlawful practice, which puts the detainee at risk. The provision that allows this
practice to continue (article 8, decree no. 670) should be rescinded immediately. Should the prosecutor authorize the police to recall a detainee for further questioning, the interview should take place at the prison in which the individual is held and not at a police station.

29 Letter to Human Rights Watch from family of victim, July 27, 2017. Human Rights Watch subsequently contacted the family
to confirm the veracity of the information contained in the letter.

30 See article 8, Decree no. 670, Resmi Gazete (Official Gazette), August 17, 2016:
http://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/eskiler/2016/08/20160817-17.htm (accessed August 1, 2017).

31 For a case from Antalya, see "12 Eylül uygulaması hortlatılıyor: Tutuklulara 'yeniden gözaltı'" (12 September practice
resurrected: "re-arresting" pretrial detention detainees), Siyasi Haber news website, January 30, 2017:
http://siyasihaber3.org/12-eylul-uygulamasi-hortlatiliyor-tutuklulara-yeniden-gozalti (accessed August 15, 2017).


Source:HRW, In Custody Police Torture and Abductions in Turkey

 


Abductions in Turkey
and abroud


Abductions in Turkey

Turkey’s Changing
Media Landscape

Anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist financing

Key human rights
violations in Turkey


Police, Watchmen Involved in Torture, Ill-Treatment
About Some sources Gladio B: Gulen & CIA.
Abduction/ missing persons Brain drain Torture.