• Afrin. Operation Olive Branch
    May - June 2018War crimes accusations"
  • Coup attemt aftermath
    AboutConfiscationsDecreesOHAL CommissionState of emergency
  • Gladio B Turkey
    About Gladio B in TurkeyJames Corbett about GladioPaul L Williams about GladioSibel Edmonds about Gladio BThe Susurluk scandalOp. Gladio documentary BBC
  • Gülen Movement
    About the Gülen MovementAbout Hanefi AvcıConservative or moderate?Documents and reportsFethullah GulenFETÖGulens intentionsGulen and jihadPersons- Leading figuresStratfor about the MovementStructure The "12 Wise Men"TerrorThe CIA connectionThe Imam's ArmyUS CablesVideos
  • Humen rights
    Human Rights Watch report 2020 TurkeyTurkey 2019 human rights reportReligious freedom reportTorture and ill-treatment
  • Media in Turkey
    About media in TurkeyJournalists in troubleMedia outlets shut downSocial mediaTurkey Crackdown on media 2016-18Who controls the media?
  • New Turkey
    Abductions in New TurkeyAbout "The New Turkey"Brain drain in New TurkeyPrisons in New TurkeyTorture in New Turkey
  • Purges
    About purges in TurkeyAcademics for peaceCHP deputiesGülen movementHDP deputiesLawyers in TurkeyMedia in Turkey
  • Sources
  • Terror attacks 2015-19
Web Page Creator
Web Page Creator
 

The new Turkey
C.G.

2-apr-19

In another case reported to Human Rights Watch, villagers from Şapatan (Altınsu) village, in the Şemdinli district of the southeast province of Hakkari, reported to the media and to lawyers that on August 6, 2017 dozens of men were rounded up from their homes by the security forces, beaten, and taken to the Şemdinli anti-terror branch where the illtreatment continued.22 A lawyer acting for the villagers told Human Rights Watch:

After an armed clash on August 5 in which a police officer was killed, the security forces entered the Şapatan village in the night and searched homes. They gathered the villagers in the middle of the village and a unit of 10-15 special team police officers and plain-clothes officers beat everyone mercilessly in the village, and at the Şemdinli Security Directorate.23

Human Rights Watch has examined three of the complaints lodged by 38 villagers. S.T., 28, told the Şemdinli prosecutor that after being made to assemble in front of the village mosque, he and the other villagers were put into armoured vehicles (Panzers) and taken to Şemdinli Security Directorate:

Four police officers who got us out of the Panzers beat us. They continued to beat us until we got to the third floor of the Security Directorate. I was also insulted. In the corridor of the anti-terror branch on the third floor we were beaten by special team police and plain-clothes police. One of the plainclothed officers who beat us was 35-50, slightly heavy, bearded, and greying.

This man beat the backs of me and the 20 I was with using a hose pipe. We had been brought to the police station in three groups. The policeman I described beat our group with a hose pipe. I am lodging a complaint against the special team police and plainclothes police who beat and insulted me. I would be able to identify those who beat me.24



Another of the villagers, C.G., complained to the prosecutor's office that the special team police had searched his home and beaten him.

Police officers whose faces I would be able to identify, knocked on the door at around 4 a.m. and, as soon as the door was opened began to beat me, insult, and swear at me. When my 80-year-old mother tried to prevent them, they beat her too. This torture continued till 6. They knocked me unconscious, and threw me onto the balcony. They cursed my wife and left our house thinking I was dead.25

N.Ş., 22, also described being repeatedly beaten while taken to the Security Directorate, and once there. In a room on the third floor a "35-40-year-old plainclothes police officer with greying hair and a beard" had addressed them:

You haven't seen anything yet, the beating is just starting," he told us… Then he made us lie down and beat our backs with a mop stick. I gave a statement about this at the Şemdinli Security Directorate. The police made me identify him. However, I was unable to identify the man who beat me from photographs. I would be able to identify the man who beat me from an identification parade. I am lodging a complaint about the special team and plain-clothes police who beat me.26

Human Rights Watch obtained photographs of some of the Şapatan villagers showing clear signs that they had been beaten in a manner consistent with their allegations. These were also published widely in the Turkish and Kurdish media, and circulated on social media. The Hakkari governorate issued a statement initially describing the torture claims as "completely baseless and intended as propaganda for a terrorist organization."27

However, inspectors were appointed to examine the incident and a police officer was suspended from duty on August 11. There is also a disciplinary investigation by the Turkish Medical Association (TTB) into a doctor at the Şemdinli hospital who was heard to insult the villagers, and to allege that they had brought the torture on themselves, and failed in her
duty to record their injuries in detail.28

Security forces in Hakkari are operating in a challenging environment. The day before the villagers were beaten, a police officer was killed in an armed clash. However, this context does not justify or excuse members of the security forces or police committing serious human rights violations, such as ill-treatment of detainees and suspects, nor does it negate the obligation to conduct effective criminal investigations into credible allegations of torture and mistreatment, and to impose appropriate disciplinary measures as required under Turkey's own laws and international law.

22 (accessed August 19, 2017, but site subsequently blocked in Turkey after the government closed down Dihaber news agency
by emergency decree no. 693, August 25, 2017). A full report on the incident based on a field visit and interviews with victims
was published in Turkish by the human rights group İnsan Hakları ve Adalet Hareketi Derneği, İHAK (Human Rights and
Justice Movement), August 2017, https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BxX8wzuz2PobWlgxaksyTU0wbm8/view (accessed
September 11, 2017).
23 Human Rights Watch telephone interview with lawyer, August 7, 2017.
24 Record of complainant S.T.'s statement to Şemdinli prosecutor, August 11, 2017, on file with Human Rights Watch.
25 Complaint to Şemdinli prosecutor, August 10, 2017, on file with Human Rights Watch.

26 Record of complainant N.Ş.'s statement to Şemdinli prosecutor, August 11, 2017, on file with Human Rights Watch.
27 Statement by the Hakkari Governorate, August 8, 2017: available at http://www.hakkari.gov.tr/basin-aciklamasi-2017261
(accessed August 9, 2017).
28 Information communicated to Human Rights Watch by lawyer, August 17, 2017.

Source:HRW, In Custody Police Torture and Abductions in Turkey

 



Human Rights Watch country report:
Events in Tyrkey 2020



Council of Europe anti-torture Committee
publishes two
reports on Turkey



Black Sites in Turkey



Advocates of silenced
Turkey report 2020

About Some sources Gladio B: Gulen & CIA.
Abduction/ missing persons Brain drain Torture